Michigan couple faces jail over lost Dr. Seuss library book from library

Published 3:42 pm Saturday, April 16, 2016

TECUMSEH, Mich. — A judge told a Michigan couple they could land in jail for up to 93 days and face a maximum $500 fine for failing to return a novel and a Dr. Seuss book borrowed from the local public library.

Cathy and Melvin Duren of Tecumseh, Michigan, appeared in Lenawee County court on Thursday to each face a misdemeanor charge of failure to return rental property. They owe about $35 in late fees for “The Rome Prophecy,” borrowed in April 2015. They lost a Dr. Seuss book their teenage son borrowed for their granddaughter in July 2014.

“I can’t imaginee going to jail over it, but I certainly will fight these charges because I’m not guilty,” Cathy Duren said.

Email newsletter signup

Although the couple admitted they were negligent in returning the books, they think it’s unfair to each be charged a $105 “diversion fee” to the Lenawee County Economic Crimes Unit in addition to fines owed to the Tecumseh Public Library.

In December, the Durens received a letter advising them to return the books and pay the fees, as well as the replacement costs if they couldn’t find the books. The letter also informed them that they could be charged with a crime.

In January, the couple was able to find and return “The Rome Prophecy,” but they couldn’t locate the Dr. Seuss book. The title of the book wasn’t known.

Cathy Duren sent a $55 money order to the prosecutor’s office to cover the late fees and replacement costs for the lost book.