Print this story | E-mail story | This story has 10 comments Add your own | iPod friendly | Bookmark this Facebook bookmark del.icio.us bookmark StumbleUpon bookmark Digg bookmark What is this?

What incentives are there for dog training?

Published Tuesday, July 29, 2008

I know how Snoopy felt in the 1972 animated film “Snoopy Come Home” when he encounters numerous “No Dogs Allowed” signs. It is difficult for dog owners to take their pets places because most people in the world view all dogs the same. The fact is, not all dogs are equal and not all dog owners are equal. If you are the owner of an obedient and well-trained dog, don’t you wish the world made allowances for your dog’s good behavior?

Besides veterinary needs, some owners buy a leash, a stake and some dog food. Some go so far as to build a fence and a doghouse. That is fine. They are providing a loving home for a pet, and that’s the most important thing.

Other owners go further. They spend the extra time training their dogs and some spend the extra money taking their dogs to obedience classes.

My wife and I taught our dog, Alta, “sit,” “shake,” “lay,” “stay,” “roll over,” “c’mere,” “go get it,” “go poddy,” “off” and a few other commands before she entered obedience school. At school, she learned many other commands, such as “leave it,” “no tug” and how to heel, only we had to use “stay,” which to her if said during walking means to heel. Our dog is amazing. I can set out a glove, a ball and a stick and if I command “Get the glove,” she will fetch the glove. If I hold out a stick and say “up,” she will jump high for it. I can tell her “go” and she will walk away, and when I say “c’mere” she enthusiastically returns. At a playground, she will go down a slide on the command “slide.” She catches on command. She kisses on command. She jumps in a car or truck on command. She does tricks for praise, not treats. But she likes treats. I can set a treat on the ground and tell Alta to stay; she will not go eat the treat until I say, “Go get it.” Alta, of course, is housebroken. She is better at walks off the leash than on because she obeys so well.

Tim Engstrom

But laws and policies tend to view all dogs the same. It’s either dogs yes or dogs no. How come more places don’t see a difference in trained dogs?

Instead of only allowing service dogs indoors, places also should permit trained dogs, too. There is a movie theater in Roslyn, Wash., that lets well-behaved dogs in. Alta sat at our feet during “Ray” starring Jamie Foxx.

I have walked to stores with my dog on a leash, told her to lay on the sidewalk, told her to stay, dropped the leash and gone inside, made a purchase and returned to find her there waiting. Leashes really are for the visual benefit of other people, who are comforted to know I have control of the beast.

I understand how leashes can ease the perspective of others. A trained dog and an untrained dog look alike at first.

But if you are the owner of a trained dog, don’t you sometimes feel society gives little reward to you for the time and money you invested in obedience school? Don’t you wish the graduation certificate could function as a permission slip to bring your dog in stores or at least more stores than at present? Or even into government buildings and places such as trains, bus stations and shopping malls?

To their credit, some places allow dogs. Some bars that don’t serve hardly any food allow dogs. Farm-supply places as the Albert Lea Seed House let dogs come in. You can bring your dog in when you come to the Albert Lea Tribune to renew your subscription. We simply trust you wouldn’t bring in an unruly or dirty dog.

Lisa and I were in Park Rapids with our 1 1/2-year-old son and Alta this past weekend. We had to kill time Friday before we could check into our cabin, so we walked downtown. First we bought a leash for Alta — for the sake of others. Then we visited the stores, usually with Lisa and our son going inside and Alta and I standing outside panting and sweating. When it came time to eat, Alta and I ate outdoors at Main Street Meats, which had a sidewalk stand because it was Crazy Days. The girls at Main Street Meats gave Alta a burned brat for no charge. After I ate, I did the stay-and-dropped-leash thing with Alta, and I went inside to purchase eight brats. (Best brats I have ever tasted!) Lisa and Forrest went to a sandwich shop and ate in the comfort of air conditioning.

Many hotels and motels are starting to be better about dogs but most are not. It often seems the more upscale the lodging is, the less anal it is about pets. The place we stayed in Park Rapids allowed dogs, but it had strict rules. We broke the rules because A. they were unreasonable (for one, I’m not going to keep Alta caged while we are out) and B. the innkeeper hadn’t told us the rules when we made the reservation (thus, we didn’t have a cage with us). The luxurious Fairmont Olympic Hotel in downtown Seattle treated Alta like a cherished guest. The staff loved her.

A great example of my point is leash laws. Some folks think leash laws mean dogs must be attached to leashes. However, many people argue commands for an obedient dog act as a “vocal leash.” If your dog heels and won’t chase dogs, birds, cats, squirrels, children and such, then shouldn’t you and your dog be rewarded for the training and not need a leash?

Rarely, as I walk Alta, someone will holler, “That dog ought to be on a leash.” I ignore them but I feel like saying, “Hey, I paid for obedience classes. That is the leash.”

The world wants owners to train their dogs but offers few incentives for it. Sure, you have a happier dog and a better relationship because your pooch understands what you ask, but what about once you step off your property? It seems everywhere wants dogs bound.

If the world wants dogs that behave, the key is giving dog owners more incentives.

Tribune Managing Editor Tim Engstrom’s column appears every Tuesday.


WOULD YOU LIKE TO SHARE THIS STORY?

Bookmark and Share



Comments

Posted by 2gr8danes (Lori Meyer) on July 29, 2008 at 10:56 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Amen! I have no problem keeping the dogs on a leash. As you said, sometimes it keeps others more comfortable. I don't expect every person in the world to love my dogs, I do expect them to accept the fact that I do.

I would gladly keep the dogs on a 6' leash if I could take them places with me. I take them every where I can and the more they get to go the more they learn to behave.

The CGC (Canine Good Citizen)is the AKC's award for a well behaved dog and it should be a requirement for every dog allowed in a public place to get one! They must go through training and pass a test to receive the certificate. It doesn't have anything to do with dog shows or anything like that. Any dog can get one whether they are a purebred or a mixed breed dog. They can and should all learn to behave.

Posted by justmealmn (anonymous) on July 29, 2008 at 1:25 p.m. (Suggest removal)

I would hope since you have your photo on here, that the ALPD Animal Control Officer would keep an eye out for you and your unleashed dog. Your the same as any others breaking the law by NOT having it on one each time your out walking. I suppose you figure you don't need to pickup after it either. BUT then again you probably have IT trained to do ITS job on demand too. I'll look forward to seeing your name in the Trib for a dog unleached ticket.

Posted by BullDogBagCo (anonymous) on July 29, 2008 at 1:33 p.m. (Suggest removal)

No matter how much training a dog receives, one must remember that a dog is still a dog and that their owners are ultimately responsible for anything their dog does.

www.Bulldogbagcompany.com
Simplify your (dog's) life!

Posted by the_truth (anonymous) on July 29, 2008 at 11:44 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Do you know why there are rules and leash laws? It's because no matter how "perfect", how "trained" your dog is, it's still a dog. Every dog, no matter how ideal, will bite and attack someone at some point in their life. They are dogs. It's what they do. So as far as your elitist rantings are concerned, get a clue! Your pet may be perfect in your eyes, but ask that 12 year old with facial scars from a dog attack if she feels the same.

Posted by Grumpus (anonymous) on July 30, 2008 at 10:22 a.m. (Suggest removal)

The dog, in this case, anyway, is just another example of what the younger set refers to as 'bling.'

"Look at me! Look at my well-trained, expensive dog! Look at my (Lexus/Mercedes/Audi/BMW; you know it's one of these) expensive car! Look at my wife's...," well, you get the picture.

I love my cat. He doesn't need to be part of a one-person, one-pet play called Look at Me!

Elitist B.S. like this proves that you know nothing about being part of the community you pretend to report on.

Get a clue, indeed. Grab some humility, while you're at it.

Posted by wingo (anonymous) on July 31, 2008 at 9:24 a.m. (Suggest removal)

I have a dog, I love my dog, but I would never drag her every place I go. Too often I have seen pets left in cars to succomb to the heat or cold. I have never understood why people think they have to take their pets with them every where they go.
Service animals have a job, it is their job to go with the owners to help them out. I think it is really great that animals can be trained to do this. I don't think a pet, no matter what training it gets should be compared to a service animal.
I am glad so many love animals and want them with them, but be realistic. Their are too many people that are afraid of animals and we need to consider their feelings also.

Posted by tengstrom (Tim Engstrom) on July 31, 2008 at 3:08 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Grumpus:
My dog cost $15 at a dog pound when she was 3 1/2 months old. She is a mutt. She is a Lab-terrier mix. How is my column in any away "elitist"? I came from a poor, rural Iowa family, served the Gulf War in the Airborne and put myself through college on the GI Bill and side jobs. So I like my dog, think training her is good and want to be rewarded for my efforts. That makes me elitist? Bah!

The_Truth:
My dog has never bitten anyone. There are dogs that do not bite. Perhaps you have not encountered one.

Posted by the_truth (anonymous) on July 31, 2008 at 8:54 p.m. (Suggest removal)

tengstrom...

ALL dogs bite... maybe not you, maybe not today, but someday they will bite... what are all those teeth for if not for biting?

Your idea of having special privledges is an elitist one, so naturally, I would surmize that you are an elitist. You don't have to be born of royal blood to be an elitist. It's a mindset.

Better get some ken-l-ration for your dog... since your dog is better than my dog.

Jack@$$

Posted by rdubb (anonymous) on July 31, 2008 at 10:51 p.m. (Suggest removal)

How ironic that your moniker is "the_truth."
Let me take a stab at answering your question: "What are all those teeth for if not for biting?" -- Dogs, like numerous mammal species, use their teeth to chew food down to a size that's manageable for swallowing.

Your comments don't sound like the truth to me. In fact, they fall a football field short of even qualifying as "truthiness."

PS: My nine-year-old Yorkshire Terrier has never bitten anyone. I'm going to apply for her re-enlistment in the category of "ALL dogs" if that's OK with you.

Posted by tengstrom (Tim Engstrom) on August 2, 2008 at 11:17 a.m. (Suggest removal)

You know, I tend to think the United States is the best country. So do most Americans. Does that make me and all those other patriots "elitists"? Look, there is no harm in pride. What's elitist with neighborhood pride? What's elitist with pride in my dog or my children or my town or my school? Nothing. Elitist has become a red-herring term used to distract people from the issues. It's the old political divide-and-conquer tactic. You've fallen prey to it.

Post a comment (Terms of Use Policy)

The Tribune encourages healthy, respectful dialogue in the spirit of community enlightenment. It's OK to disagree, but be courteous and civil. Name-calling, vulgarity and claims of criminality are subject to removal.

(Requires free registration.)

Username:
Password: (Forgotten your password?)

Comment:




advanced search

© 2010 Albert Lea Tribune, Inc. All rights reserved.
A Boone Newspapers Inc. publication.

Contact us | Privacy Policy