It is one thing to rise within the structure of Minnesota politics and then run for Senate. It is another to be a celebrity and then run for Senate.

Republican incumbent Sen. Norm Coleman was the mayor of St. Paul before running for Senate. He knows Minnesota. Comedian challenger Al Franken definitely is familiar with American politics — he has authored best-selling books — but we doubt whether he is familiar enough with Minnesotans.

Franken indeed grew up in Minnesota and even for a time in Albert Lea. We like that about him.

But we doubt whether Franken would be in the state if it weren’t for his national political aspirations. We suggest he run for local offices before he shoots for the Senate.

Franken seems to be running on his famous name and a victory surely would rekindle his celebrity opportunities down the road. It worked for former Gov. Jesse Ventura, but least the pro wrestler had been a mayor of the sixth-largest city in Minnesota before he ran for governor.

Coleman, even if he ends up in a Senate minority, would get more done for Minnesota. Amy Klobuchar already is established and respected among Democrats, which likely will find themselves in the Senate majority. It would be helpful for the state to have senators on both sides of the aisle. It is worth noting that Coleman is a former Democrat.

Plus, we would imagine senators of any party would be able to work easier with Coleman than they would with a celebrity. Imagine their view: Would the statements they tell Franken in D.C. circles be lampooned down the road? Is Franken in it for Minnesota or in it for Franken? It is tough to get down to brass tacks with a celebrity in the room.

Washington needs politicians willing to reduce the bipartisanship. We aren’t convinced that Franken fits the bill.

Coleman does.

Coleman also gets high marks from the National Education Association — a good sign he is his own thinker — and he has fought the good fight for veterans, among many other issues where he has been responsive to state needs.

The Coleman-Franken race has been ugly, but that’s the fault of both candidates. Ignore the TV commercials. Look at the qualities of the men.

When you add it up, Coleman is the better man. He deserves your vote.