Should judge decide washout case?
Published 9:44 am Friday, November 18, 2011
The lawyer representing Freeborn County in a lawsuit stemming from the 2008 washout on Freeborn County Road 34 is asking for a judge to determine the outcome of the case without needing a full trial.
Freeborn County District Judge Steve Schwab has 90 days to issue a ruling on Minneapolis lawyer Joseph Langel’s motion for summary judgment.
The lawsuit is related to a crash on June 29, 2008, when a 2003 Chevy Avalanche that had six people inside reportedly drove around the right side of “road closed” barricades and crashed into an embankment in an area of road that washed out.
The washout originated during heavy storms the night of June 11. The rain raised the level of a drainage ditch that eventually flows into Orchard Creek to the southeast, and that high water washed away the culvert and roadway. The washout was on County 34 between County 21 and 19.
The driver of the crashed sports-utility truck, Charles Kenneth Dennison, was found to have a blood-alcohol level of 0.16 when measured via blood sample two hours after the crash.
Court files state Dennison’s passengers were Nathan Buchli of Albert Lea in the front seat and four people in the back seat: Langdon Bachtle of Myrtle, Kelly Jo Abrego of Myrtle, Kelly John Pechumer of Albert Lea and Broc Dempewolf of Albert Lea.
Abrego and Pechumer died as a result of injuries sustained in the wreck. Abrego is Dennison’s aunt and her three children are his cousins. Buchli is also his cousin.
Dennison is serving a two-year prison sentence related to criminal charges from the case.
Buchli, Bachtle, Dempewolf and the family of Abrego and Pechumer are alleging Freeborn County, who is responsible for the maintenance of the road, was negligible and careless.
The suit — which actually is five lawsuits consolidated into one — alleges the county failed to properly warn drivers of the areas of danger, failed to properly inspect the area, failed to repair the area and failed to install and maintain proper barriers.
“As a direct and proximate result of negligence and carelessness (of Freeborn County), she sustained injuries that caused her death,” state documents in Abrego’s file.
A judge already issued summary judgment in favor of Freeborn County in a separate lawsuit involving a crash on the road in the early morning of June 12 — just hours after the washout occurred — in which Albert Lea man Dale Wangen, 52, died after the car he was driving struck the same embankment and submerged in water in an area of road that washed out.
Wangen was found after authorities received a call that a second motorist had gone off the road in the washout. The caller stated that the driver of the vehicle was unhurt but unable to get to solid ground because of the rushing water.
Though that driver was brought safely to solid ground, upon rescue he informed enforcement officials that his vehicle was actually resting on top of another vehicle that was completely submerged within the washout area.
After a rapid-water recovery of the submerged vehicle, the Albert Lea Fire Department raised the second vehicle and found Wangen deceased inside.
The lawsuit involving the June 29 crash also alleges Lyle Liquor — where the friends had been for several hours late June 28 and early June 29, 2008 — illegally sold intoxicating liquor to Dennison, who was underage at the time.
“As a direct and proximate cause of the illegal sales of intoxicating liquor by (Lyle Liquor), Charles Dennison was unable to adequately protect himself or his passengers and avoid the series injuries of his passengers,” one of the files states.
Lyle Liquor is denying the allegations, according to court documents.
Phone calls to Langel were left unreturned Thursday.
The suits were filed in June and July 2010.